Coding style standards

Prerequisites

If you want to follow along with this recipe, make sure you have:

• A web server with a Kirby Starterkit. You can also use your own project or plugin.
• Composer installed on your machine (or in a Docker container).
• The IDE related parts will cover VS Code and PHPStorm, if you don't use any of these, just skip those parts.
• Optional: Git for version control (if you put the Starterkit/your test project under version control, you can easily undo all changes we introduce in the following).

I also assume that you are familiar with using a terminal (i.e. you can navigate to a folder and execute commands).

Why are coding (style) standards important?

If you're the only person writing code or writing for yourself, this may not be a big deal, but if you want to share your code with the world, or you are collaborating in a team, adhering to coding standards becomes increasingly important.

Just imagine multiple developers working on the same code base, and everyone using their own style preferences: Some use spaces for indentation some tabs, some prefer long form arrays some short form, some name their variables and functions using snake_case, some use camelCase, some prefer Yoda style comparisons, some don't. And the list goes on. I've seen it all to often: you quickly end up with hideous and messy code.

The disadvantages of mixing different coding styles (leaving aesthetics aside) are obvious:

• Higher cognitive load when trying to understand such code
• Increased likelihood of introducing errors as a result

When working in a team, the hardest part is probably to get everyone to agree on a common standard and then stick to it, even if you don't agree with all your team's decisions. For the sake of code readability, it pays to compromise.

The good new is: Once you have you tool of choice set up, you can easily unify your complete code base with a single command.

PHP coding style standards

Let's briefly introduce some PHP coding standards.

The FIG (Framework Interoperability Group) is an organisation that defines basic standards for PHP code, the PSR guidelines. Over the years, variations of the basic PSR-1 standard have evolved. At the time of writing, PSR-12 is the current recommended coding style standard. It has superseded the former PSR-2 standard. All major PHP frameworks have adopted these standards as a basis, and the Kirby core code is also based on PSR-12.

The introduction to the PSR-12 standard states its intention like this:

…the intent of this specification is to reduce cognitive friction when scanning code from different authors. It does so by enumerating a shared set of rules and expectations about how to format PHP code.

Since the PSR guidelines don't specify rules for all situations, frameworks like Symfony or Laravel or Kirby usually add their own rules on top.

It is worth noting that in addition to those mentioned above there are other standards like PEAR or Zend.

While there are good reasons to adhere to an official standard, you may agree to deviate from these "official" standards and implement your own. Either way, the most important thing is that you agree on rules and find ways to enforce them.

However, old habits die hard (especially when working in different contexts), and if we had to fix every violation manually, it would be very frustrating and a big waste of time. Time we could spend programming or enjoying or lives, and this is where helpful tools come in that do this job for us.

Tools

I will skip IDE-specific plugins and concentrate on tools which can be used IDE-independently and which also allow us to automate things in the long run.

The most popular tools are

• PHP CS Fixer
• PHP CodeSniffer

While doing research for this recipe, I also found another interesting tool, Easy Coding Standard. It lets us combine the rules of the two tools mentioned above, which can be very useful in certain situations. Check it out if this sounds interesting to you, we won't cover it here.

Let's start with installing these tools one after the other via Composer.

PHP CS Fixer

Symfony's PHP Coding Standards Fixer is widely used, has many configuration options and dedicated plugins for VS Code, PHPStorm, Sublime Text and a few more IDEs.

Installation

PHP CS Fixer can be installed both globally or locally in your project. It's totally up to you, but we will install it globally in this recipe to make our lives easier.

Open a terminal and type the following command:

composer global require friendsofphp/php-cs-fixer

This will add the package to your global .composer/vendor folder.

composer global remove friendsofphp/php-cs-fixer

We test if installation was successful by calling php-cs-fixer with the -h option, which will show us some help text:

php-cs-fixer -h

Fixing issues

Let's see how we can use PHP CS Fixer on our code. While the Starterkit is not the ideal code base for our recipe, it is good enough to understand what the tools can do for us and how they work.

The default command to actually fix some code would be:

php-cs-fixer fix /path/to/code

This command would fix all issues in all files in the specified folder. We do a dry run first that doesn't actually make any changes, just to see what would be fixed in the /site folder.

In your terminal, go to the root of your Kirby Starterkit (cd path/to/your/starterkit), then type:

php-cs-fixer fix site --dry-run --rules=@PSR12 --diff

These are the options and arguments explained in detail:

fix: Fixes a directory or a file
site: directory to fix
--dry-run: Only show changes without actually applying them
--rules: Rules to apply, here PSR12
--diff: Show before/after differences

The output of this command will look something like this (shortened):

Loaded config default.
   1) site/snippets/blocks/image.php
      ---------- begin diff ----------
--- /Users/sonja/sites/fixer-kit/site/snippets/blocks/image.php
+++ /Users/sonja/sites/fixer-kit/site/snippets/blocks/image.php
@@ -31,9 +31,9 @@
 }

 if ($ratio !== 'auto') {
-  $ratio = Str::split($ratio, '/');
-  $w = $ratio[0] ?? 1;
-  $h = $ratio[1] ?? 1;
+    $ratio = Str::split($ratio, '/');
+    $w = $ratio[0] ?? 1;
+    $h = $ratio[1] ?? 1;
 }

 $attrs = attr([

      ----------- end diff -----------

The information the output gives us means that the indentation of the code would be changed. To actually apply the suggested changes, call the command again, this time without the dry-run parameter.

Ok, great. However, having to remember a command with all options and parameters and typing them into the command line will get tedious pretty quick.

Configuration file

Therefore, our next step will be to set up a configuration file.

In the root of your project, create a new file called .php-cs-fixer.dist.php. You can find more about the configuration in the PHP CS Fixer documentation.

In order to trigger some changes in the code and see how powerful this is, we'll add some rules in addition to the PSR-12 standard:

<?php

// define which files should be analyzed
$finder = PhpCsFixer\Finder::create()
    ->exclude(__DIR__ . '/site/plugins')
    ->in(__DIR__ . '/site')
;

$config = new PhpCsFixer\Config();
return $config
    ->setRules([
        '@PSR12' => true,
        'array_syntax' => ['syntax' => 'long'],
    ])
    ->setRiskyAllowed(true)
    ->setFinder($finder)
;

These rules are only for demonstration purposes. You can undo them later using Git.

Now let's call PHP CS Fixer again, this time without the --dry-run and --rules options.

php-cs-fixer fix --diff

As you can see, once you have your rules in place, you can easily apply your standards over the complete code base with a single command. Isn't that cool?

Usage with VS Code

There are multiple extensions tagged with PHP CS Fixer in the VS Code plugin list, but let's use the one from the official documentation. In VS Code, search for "junstyle php cs fixer" and install it.

Once the plugin is installed, we have to set some configuration settings. Click on the cog icon and select Extension Settings from the context menu. Make sure that the Execute PHP CS Fixer on save option is enabled.

Your settings.json should then have the following entries for the extension:

"php-cs-fixer.onsave": true,
"php-cs-fixer.executablePath": "${extensionPath}/php-cs-fixer.phar",

All other settings will come from our configuration file. Your code should now get fixed according to the set rules whenever you save a PHP file.

Usage with PHPStorm

If you use PHPStorm as your IDE, go to Preferences > PHP > Quality Tools. Then under PHP CS Fixer, check the ON checkbox, leave the configuration at System PHP and click on the three dots. Then select the path to the PHP CS Fixer executable in your user's Composer vendor folder which we installed earlier.

Under Options > Ruleset, select Custom and then your .php-cs-fixer.dist.php configuration file.

Next, still in Preferences, go to Editor > Inspections > PHP > Quality Tools, click on PHP CS Fixer inspection. In the inspections window, enablePHP CS Fixer validation if not yet enabled.

PHPStorm will now automatically highlight any PHP CS Fixer issues and offer to fix the complete file you are currently editing. Of course, you can also fix all files.

For other supported IDEs, check out the links to available plugins in the PHP CS Fixer documentation which you can find below.

CodeSniffer

The second tool we will look into, is PHP_CodeSniffer. It comes with two PHP scripts:

• The phpcs script tokenizes PHP, JavaScript and CSS files to detect violations of a defined coding standard, while
• the phpcbf script will actually correct all violations that it can fix automatically.

For CodeSniffer there are also plugins for several IDEs, and PHPStorm supports it out of the box. But one step after the other.

Installation

Again, we install globally via Composer:

composer global require squizlabs/php_codesniffer

Let's test if we can use it by calling it with the -h option to show the help:

phpcs -h

Basic usage

Checking your code

To check for coding style violations, we use the phpcs script…

either on a single file

phpcs /path/to/my-php-script.php

… or on a complete directory

phpcs /path/to/directory

To test against PSR-12, we use the --standard option set to the desired ruleset:

phpcs --standard=PSR12 /path/to/directory

Fixing your code

To actually fix all fixable coding style violations, we use the phpcbf command

phpcbf --standard=PSR12 /path/to/directory

Configuration

As mentioned above, Codesniffer needs an .xml configuration file. Let's create .phpcs.xml with some basic rules:

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<ruleset
        xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
        xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="./vendor/squizlabs/php_codesniffer/phpcs.xsd">

    <arg name="basepath" value="."/>
    <arg name="cache" value=".phpcs-cache"/>
    <arg name="colors"/>
    <arg name="extensions" value="php"/>
    <arg name="parallel" value="80"/>

    <!-- Show progress -->
    <arg value="p"/>

    <!-- Paths to check -->
    <file>site</file>
     <exclude-pattern>site/plugins/*</exclude-pattern>

    <!-- Include all rules from PSR-12 Coding Standard -->
    <rule ref="PSR12"/>

    <rule ref="Generic.Arrays.DisallowShortArraySyntax"/>
</ruleset>

With this file in place, we can now call the script without any arguments:

phpcs

Here is some example output for a single file:

FILE: site/controllers/album.php
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FOUND 3 ERRORS AFFECTING 3 LINES
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1 | ERROR | [x] Header blocks must be separated by a single blank line
 10 | ERROR | [x] Header blocks must be separated by a single blank line
 19 | ERROR | [x] Function closing brace must go on the next line following the body; found 1
    |       |     blank lines before brace
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PHPCBF CAN FIX THE 3 MARKED SNIFF VIOLATIONS AUTOMATICALLY
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Time: 107ms; Memory: 6MB

This tells us that there are three issues, and that all issues marked with an x can be fixed automatically when we call the phpcbf script.

Let's do this:

phpcbf

Usage with VS Code

In VS Code, install the phpcs extension.

Once the extension is installed, click on the settings cog and select Extension settings. Optionally, add the path to the phpcs executable.

Usage with PHPStorm

Integrating CodeSniffer with PHPStorm works basically the same way as with PHP CS Fixer with the only difference that this time you have to select both the path to the phpcs and the phpcbf executable.

Comparing results

The results we get from both tools with the above rules are similar, while not exactly the same. The differences are mainly due to CodeSniffer applying blank lines in some places while PHP CS Fixer doesn't.

In any case, we can configure each of these tools with very fine-grained rules to our liking. Consult the documentation and other resources linked below to find out more.

Where to go from here: Automation

The approaches we have seen above are all nice and well and work fine for a single disciplined user.

But things we have to do manually are easily forgotten. And while IDEs do a good job when fixing stuff automatically when saving, your IDE might not support the chosen tool, or external code contributors are not familiar with setting up these tools.

So the question is: how can we prevent that badly styled code ever lands in our repos with the least friction? The answer is: automation.

We can implement automatic checks at different stages in the lifecycle (i.e. before code is staged or committed, before it is pushed, before it is merged) and either reject it or fix it automatically where possible.

There are at least two approaches:

• Git hooks
• CI/CD pipelines (for example GitHub actions or GitLab CI/CD

It would be too much to cover these automation options in this recipe. So we leave it for a future one.

Resources

PHP coding standards

• Some of the most followed PHP Standards and Coding-styles
• Run Prettier or PHP CS Fixer with GitHub Actions

PHP CS Fixer

• How to create custom rules
• PHP CS Fixer configurator: Nice third party overview of rules
• Sharing PHP CS Fixer rules across projects and teams
• Using PHP CS Fixer in PHPStorm

Codesniffer

• CodeSniffer wiki
• Annotated ruleset
• Ruleset generator